"O Canada" Revised

Started by andyw2100, February 01, 2018, 09:50:57 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

andyw2100

https://www.cnn.com/2018/02/01/americas/canada-gender-neutral-national-anthem-trnd/index.html

---
Canada's Senate has passed a bill making the country's national anthem gender-neutral.

If you're not familiar with the words to "O Canada," here's how the first few lines of the English version originally read: O Canada! / Our home and native land! / True patriot love in all thy sons command.
The bill changes the phrase "in all thy sons command" to "in all of us command."
It must now receive "royal assent" from the governor general before it becomes law.

Jeff Hopkins '82

I for one will continue to sing the current lyrics.  Political correctness be damned!

RichH

The song has had as many versions as Cornell's Alma Mater has verses.

http://faze.ca/canada-national-anthem-through-history/

Roy 82

Quote from: Jeff Hopkins '82I for one will continue to sing the current lyrics.  Political correctness be damned!

Why? I gladly welcome the more inclusive lyrics since it makes many people feel better and does no harm to me.

redliner

Quote from: Roy 82
Quote from: Jeff Hopkins '82I for one will continue to sing the current lyrics.  Political correctness be damned!

Why? I gladly welcome the more inclusive lyrics since it makes many people feel better and does no harm to me.

I think he was being sarcastic. Though, you can never quite tell on the internet...

Trotsky


Jeff Hopkins '82

Quote from: redliner
Quote from: Roy 82
Quote from: Jeff Hopkins '82I for one will continue to sing the current lyrics.  Political correctness be damned!

Why? I gladly welcome the more inclusive lyrics since it makes many people feel better and does no harm to me.

I think he was being sarcastic. Though, you can never quite tell on the internet...

No, I was serious.

Jim Hyla

Quote from: Jeff Hopkins '82
Quote from: redliner
Quote from: Roy 82
Quote from: Jeff Hopkins '82I for one will continue to sing the current lyrics.  Political correctness be damned!

Why? I gladly welcome the more inclusive lyrics since it makes many people feel better and does no harm to me.

I think he was being sarcastic. Though, you can never quite tell on the internet...

No, I was serious.

But why? Why would you go against what a country and its people want? If they change their anthem and if you want to support our Canadian players, why wouldn't you sing what they say is their anthem?

Putting it another way, if you were standing next to a player from Canada and the two of you were singing, would you really go against the words that he, or she, were using?

What we sing is not an issue of political correctness, but rather respect for their country and their, not our, wishes.
"Cornell Fans Made the Timbers Tremble", Boston Globe, March/1970
Cornell lawyers stopped the candy throwing. Jan/2005

Tcl123

Quote from: Jim Hyla
Quote from: Jeff Hopkins '82
Quote from: redliner
Quote from: Roy 82
Quote from: Jeff Hopkins '82I for one will continue to sing the current lyrics.  Political correctness be damned!

Why? I gladly welcome the more inclusive lyrics since it makes many people feel better and does no harm to me.

I think he was being sarcastic. Though, you can never quite tell on the internet...

No, I was serious.

But why? Why would you go against what a country and its people want? If they change their anthem and if you want to support our Canadian players, why wouldn't you sing what they say is their anthem?

Putting it another way, if you were standing next to a player from Canada and the two of you were singing, would you really go against the words that he, or she, were using?

What we sing is not an issue of political correctness, but rather respect for their country and their, not our, wishes.

How do you know what the people want? Was it voted on?

Give My Regards

Quote from: toddlose
Quote from: Jim Hyla
Quote from: Jeff Hopkins '82
Quote from: redliner
Quote from: Roy 82
Quote from: Jeff Hopkins '82I for one will continue to sing the current lyrics.  Political correctness be damned!

Why? I gladly welcome the more inclusive lyrics since it makes many people feel better and does no harm to me.

I think he was being sarcastic. Though, you can never quite tell on the internet...

No, I was serious.

But why? Why would you go against what a country and its people want? If they change their anthem and if you want to support our Canadian players, why wouldn't you sing what they say is their anthem?

Putting it another way, if you were standing next to a player from Canada and the two of you were singing, would you really go against the words that he, or she, were using?

What we sing is not an issue of political correctness, but rather respect for their country and their, not our, wishes.

How do you know what the people want? Was it voted on?

According to the article, the bill was passed by the House of Commons and the Senate.  So yes, at least the people's representatives did.
If you lead a good life, go to Sunday school and church, and say your prayers every night, when you die, you'll go to LYNAH!

Trotsky

Stop.  Please stop.  Everybody please just stop.

Hell is other people's politics.  Please keep eLynah free of politics.

cufan

Hell is other people's politics. Please keep eLynah free of politics.

Thank You

underskill

Trudeau sucks and nobody cares or asked for this.

andyw2100


ugarte

Quote from: TrotskyStop.  Please stop.  Everybody please just stop.

Hell is other people's politics.  Please keep eLynah free of politics.
lol