[OT] Joe's Restaurant Reopening

hymn · January 24, 2006, 08:33:08 PM

I went there last night. I'm a food snob after working in a ton of restaurants in a big city and catering for years. i wanna say, Joe's rocks! There were lots of people there. And everything was great for my table (and the table behind us). Go to Joe's. (You gotta ask for croutons for yer salad if you want them, but they got croutons)- my only comment other than, "perfect".

DeltaOne81 · January 24, 2006, 09:14:00 PM

[quote hymn]I went there last night. I'm a food snob after working in a ton of restaurants in a big city and catering for years. i wanna say, Joe's rocks! There were lots of people there. And everything was great for my table (and the table behind us). Go to Joe's. (You gotta ask for croutons for yer salad if you want them, but they got croutons)- my only comment other than, "perfect".[/quote]

If this was a paid marketing move, its genius

I have no idea about the quality of the new Joes, nor have much to compare it against because I'd only been to the original once and that was in its declining years.

But just the claim of a "food snob" rating it perfect, when a previous non-snob's review was so-so... makes me wonder

marty · February 05, 2006, 08:06:00 PM

[quote DeltaOne81][quote hymn]I went there last night. I'm a food snob after working in a ton of restaurants in a big city and catering for years. i wanna say, Joe's rocks! There were lots of people there. And everything was great for my table (and the table behind us). Go to Joe's. (You gotta ask for croutons for yer salad if you want them, but they got croutons)- my only comment other than, "perfect".[/quote]

If this was a paid marketing move, its genius

I have no idea about the quality of the new Joes, nor have much to compare it against because I'd only been to the original once and that was in its declining years.

But just the claim of a "food snob" rating it perfect, when a previous non-snob's review was so-so... makes me wonder

[/quote]

I'd say you hit the nail on the head, DeltaOne. It was no where near perfect.

Will we try again? Yes. Will we visit a third time under this ownership? That's up to them!::wtf::

Trotsky · February 22, 2006, 06:58:53 PM

My review after the first meal at the new (reopened, whatever) restaurant.

Meh. Nice atmosphere. Very, very slow service. Food was nothing to write home about, but I started very safe (spaghetti, meat sauce, meat balls, a few appetizer tastes).

But,

(1) beats the hell out of anything else on offer
(2) quiet atmosphere
(3) they will, indeed, serve you beer in a wine carafe

B+, but I'd go back.

jtwcornell91 · February 22, 2006, 11:22:34 PM

They have all the stuff I remember going to Joe's for: bottomless salad, breadsticks, and kick-ass chicken marsala. Now if only Billy Bob Jack's would re-open...

cornelldavy · February 23, 2006, 01:08:36 AM

[quote jtwcornell91]They have all the stuff I remember going to Joe's for: bottomless salad, breadsticks, and kick-ass chicken marsala. Now if only Billy Bob Jack's would re-open...[/quote]

BBJ's closed? The one by the Pyramid Mall? Aw hell no!

Rosey · February 23, 2006, 01:13:48 AM

[quote cornelldavy]BBJ's closed? The one by the Pyramid Mall? Aw hell no![/quote]
Both of them are closed. I was crushed when I found out walking down Dryden in January. I have a lot of fond memories of both restaurants.

Kyle

RichH · February 23, 2006, 09:40:05 AM

[quote krose][quote cornelldavy]BBJ's closed? The one by the Pyramid Mall? Aw hell no![/quote]
Both of them are closed. I was crushed when I found out walking down Dryden in January. I have a lot of fond memories of both restaurants.[/quote]
So with the demise of BBJBBQS and BistroQ/Buffalo St. BBQ, what 'Que options does that leave Ithaca? Dinosaur in Syracuse/Rochester? The "awsome blossom" at Chilis? Applebee's riblets?? ::panic:: ::cry::

Oh wait...I forgot about Ralph's Ribs. Please tell me that Ralph's Ribs is still open.

Now what Collegetown *really* needs is some sort of asian restaurant.

redhair34 · February 23, 2006, 12:53:20 PM

[quote RichH] Please tell me that Ralph's Ribs is still open.[/quote]

It is!

KeithK · February 23, 2006, 04:25:43 PM

[quote krose]Both of them are closed. I was crushed when I found out walking down Dryden in January. I have a lot of fond memories of both restaurants.

Kyle[/quote]Me too. Well, the one by Pyramid anyway - the one in C-town wasn't as good. It didn't have the 49er anyway. Man, that means my listings on the toilet seat are gone forever! How sad.

Edit: I like obscure references, but this one I think I'd better clarify. I mean the toilet seat on the wall in the lobby, next to the plaque.

Robb · February 24, 2006, 11:04:36 PM

What was your time for the 49er? I seem to remember something about a ridiculous time, but my brain can't seem to recall whether that was yours or someone else's (Dan?) or maybe someone we don't even know...

billhoward · March 15, 2006, 01:42:00 AM

So who's actually been there? How's the food and service? We thought of Joe's for the pre-Saturday-Clarkson dinner but the small sampling of opininons we got was: service can be slow ... food's okay to good, not good to great. So we wound up at Nines.

jaybert · March 15, 2006, 11:27:21 AM

I was there this weekend, it was late so it was not busy at all.

service was decent, and food arrived quickly. I enjoyed my shrimp scampi but my gf's lasagna wasnt the best.

The breadsticks were really good. the unlimited salad was pretty good, but the dressing was a little sweet, but still good.

overall, I enjoyed it, and will probably return when I get a chance.