11/14/2026 Cornell at Yale

Started by Sperris, November 14, 2026, 06:18:10 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Iceberg

The Cornell Sports YouTube channel shows it on the game highlights. It sure looks like Long moved his right foot toward the puck and I don't see how it would've gone toward the net otherwise. The overhead view doesn't show it as clearly but there is a side view that does.

Snowball

There was a fair amount of play to like in this game: Rousseau was consistent and had some marvelous saves. There was good play form many: Cato of course, Zad, Pirtle, Fegaras, Fisher, Ashton and Gorski, imho. Of the new guys I thought that Randle and Gardner were impressive, and I love the energy of Coco.

Something's off with Walshy and face-offs: he was 8 for 22 last night, and was 16 of 34 the night before. That alone had a big impact on the weekend. Upper body injury?

Consider this counterfactual: one of Walshy's shots goes in, we beat Yale, and everyone walks away feeling a little better about themselves.

Would that actually have been a good thing? I don't think so. We'd be talking about a win instead of confronting the real problems staring this team in the face. Sometimes a loss like this, one that stings for an entire weekend, is exactly what a team needs. Better to have the wheels come off the early in the season than to keep papering over the cracks. This sh— needs to get fixed, and it needs to get fixed now.

Casey's a great coach, he can get this done, I am looking forward to it.

stereax

Quote from: VIEWfromK on Today at 10:16:09 AM
Quote from: Iceberg on Today at 10:09:26 AMI'd be curious to see the overhead view of the disallowed goal again. It was briefly shown in the rink before the refs went to review it themselves but I didn't see any kicking motion. I thought the goal could have been disallowed because of the Cornell player in the crease before the shot but that's not what they were reviewing.

The angle was so high and Long had a guy draped on him that you couldn't actually see what the puck went off of.  You'd really need an in net angle to know for sure.  This was likely a case of the refs assuming it went in off his foot since you could see it wasn't his stick.  But was it an actual kicking motion?  Inconclusive
They called it a good goal on the ice. They would need conclusive evidence to overturn it.
Law '27, Section C denizen, liveblogging from Lynah!
it's ster-e-ax, like stereo

stereax

Quote from: Snowball on Today at 11:15:48 AMThere was a fair amount of play to like in this game: Rousseau was consistent and had some marvelous saves. There was good play form many: Cato of course, Zad, Pirtle, Fegaras, Fisher, Ashton and Gorski, imho. Of the new guys I thought that Randle and Gardner were impressive, and I love the energy of Coco.

Something's off with Walshy and face-offs: he was 8 for 22 last night, and was 16 of 34 the night before. That alone had a big impact on the weekend. Upper body injury?

Consider this counterfactual: one of Walshy's shots goes in, we beat Yale, and everyone walks away feeling a little better about themselves.

Would that actually have been a good thing? I don't think so. We'd be talking about a win instead of confronting the real problems staring this team in the face. Sometimes a loss like this, one that stings for an entire weekend, is exactly what a team needs. Better to have the wheels come off the early in the season than to keep papering over the cracks. This sh— needs to get fixed, and it needs to get fixed now.

Casey's a great coach, he can get this done, I am looking forward to it.
Personally, I wouldn't have felt good about a win unless it was, as I mentioned previously, an "ass-blasting" of the highest order. Winning, say, 2-1 would have been nice for my mental health, sure, but it would mean we barely edged Yale, one of the worst teams in the ECAC. If we showed up and put down 5 or 6, after that miserable Brown outing, that would have shown me that the team saw what happened the night before and said "fuck that, THAT'S not happening again", put their big boy skates on, and demolished the team playing against them. We had a good first period against Yale, and then just petered out.

Sometimes a change in net can wake a room right the fuck up. Last year, the guys played way better in front of Keopple, even if he was a worse goaltender. Maybe let Rousseau sit a game, put Roest in, see what you have there and send a message.

Agreed with your assessment that a lot of the guys individually looked good. Glad to see Pirtle back in the lineup, he always provides a spark. The freshmen have been overall quite good as well.

In re faceoffs - there are new faceoff rules league-wide. I assume that's part of it. Also, having Walshy take 34 faceoffs on a night is probably part of the issue.

Anyways. It feels like the bulk of the issue is with the forward corps - the defense has been great overall and the goalie hasn't been the problem, either. We need scoring now, and for these forward lines to click. Cato, Z, and Kraft can't be all of our scoring.

Casey will figure it out.
Law '27, Section C denizen, liveblogging from Lynah!
it's ster-e-ax, like stereo

Snowball

Agree, agree. And this is a really good point:

In re faceoffs - there are new faceoff rules league-wide. I assume that's part of it. Also, having Walshy take 34 faceoffs on a night is probably part of the issue

Bluelightning

My mind keeps coming back to Charlie Major. I don't think he has a single point yet. His +\- is team worst -5 (and he's on power play, which doesn't mean anything with Cornell).
    To me, when he is out there....there is no chemistry with anyone. If he keeps puck and gets deep, everyone else just watches. If he passes it off, everyone seems like they dont know what to do.
  I'm not a hockey expert. But I know we need Charlie to be very good. He has as much skill offensively as almost anyone on team (handling, passing, shooting)...but we aren't seeing results. We need him to be a leader both on the stat sheet and in locker room. He's a junior with a ton of experience here at Cornell. We need him to at least take control and be the leader of the 2nd line. If we don't start to get goals when he is on the ice, we won't have much success. Too much of the load is on Walsh line

VIEWfromK

Quote from: stereax on Today at 11:18:10 AM
Quote from: VIEWfromK on Today at 10:16:09 AM
Quote from: Iceberg on Today at 10:09:26 AMI'd be curious to see the overhead view of the disallowed goal again. It was briefly shown in the rink before the refs went to review it themselves but I didn't see any kicking motion. I thought the goal could have been disallowed because of the Cornell player in the crease before the shot but that's not what they were reviewing.

The angle was so high and Long had a guy draped on him that you couldn't actually see what the puck went off of.  You'd really need an in net angle to know for sure.  This was likely a case of the refs assuming it went in off his foot since you could see it wasn't his stick.  But was it an actual kicking motion?  Inconclusive
They called it a good goal on the ice. They would need conclusive evidence to overturn it.

Correct which I hope means they had an angle not available to the broadcast.  Not sure that exists in ecac though so I felt like they were assuming something by taking it away

ugarte

Quote from: stereax on Today at 11:18:10 AM
Quote from: VIEWfromK on Today at 10:16:09 AM
Quote from: Iceberg on Today at 10:09:26 AMI'd be curious to see the overhead view of the disallowed goal again. It was briefly shown in the rink before the refs went to review it themselves but I didn't see any kicking motion. I thought the goal could have been disallowed because of the Cornell player in the crease before the shot but that's not what they were reviewing.

The angle was so high and Long had a guy draped on him that you couldn't actually see what the puck went off of.  You'd really need an in net angle to know for sure.  This was likely a case of the refs assuming it went in off his foot since you could see it wasn't his stick.  But was it an actual kicking motion?  Inconclusive
They called it a good goal on the ice. They would need conclusive evidence to overturn it.
as soon as i saw the replay i turned to my friend and said that might not be good. his stick was nowhere near the puck. it wasn't a deflection; at best it was an accident from wrestling and flailing.

The Rancor

Quote from: stereax on Today at 11:53:44 AM
Quote from: Snowball on Today at 11:15:48 AMThere was a fair amount of play to like in this game: Rousseau was consistent and had some marvelous saves. There was good play form many: Cato of course, Zad, Pirtle, Fegaras, Fisher, Ashton and Gorski, imho. Of the new guys I thought that Randle and Gardner were impressive, and I love the energy of Coco.

Something's off with Walshy and face-offs: he was 8 for 22 last night, and was 16 of 34 the night before. That alone had a big impact on the weekend. Upper body injury?

Consider this counterfactual: one of Walshy's shots goes in, we beat Yale, and everyone walks away feeling a little better about themselves.

Would that actually have been a good thing? I don't think so. We'd be talking about a win instead of confronting the real problems staring this team in the face. Sometimes a loss like this, one that stings for an entire weekend, is exactly what a team needs. Better to have the wheels come off the early in the season than to keep papering over the cracks. This sh— needs to get fixed, and it needs to get fixed now.

Casey's a great coach, he can get this done, I am looking forward to it.
Personally, I wouldn't have felt good about a win unless it was, as I mentioned previously, an "ass-blasting" of the highest order. Winning, say, 2-1 would have been nice for my mental health, sure, but it would mean we barely edged Yale, one of the worst teams in the ECAC. If we showed up and put down 5 or 6, after that miserable Brown outing, that would have shown me that the team saw what happened the night before and said "fuck that, THAT'S not happening again", put their big boy skates on, and demolished the team playing against them. We had a good first period against Yale, and then just petered out.

Sometimes a change in net can wake a room right the fuck up. Last year, the guys played way better in front of Keopple, even if he was a worse goaltender. Maybe let Rousseau sit a game, put Roest in, see what you have there and send a message.

Agreed with your assessment that a lot of the guys individually looked good. Glad to see Pirtle back in the lineup, he always provides a spark. The freshmen have been overall quite good as well.

In re faceoffs - there are new faceoff rules league-wide. I assume that's part of it. Also, having Walshy take 34 faceoffs on a night is probably part of the issue.

Anyways. It feels like the bulk of the issue is with the forward corps - the defense has been great overall and the goalie hasn't been the problem, either. We need scoring now, and for these forward lines to click. Cato, Z, and Kraft can't be all of our scoring.

Casey will figure it out.

Re: Goaltending. You can't (or shouldn't) sit the goaltender, who came here to be a starter- much like he who shant be named- if he's performing as needed just to send a message to the rest of the team. I get what you are saying: "Anyone can sit, even him" but the next thing that happens is a call to his player agent to type up a portal letter. If he was giving up 5 goals on 10 shots and getting pulled in the 2nd, maybe. But as most of us, and Casey have said: it's the offense.

Also, and I might be misremembering a Schefer quote, but they can't score if we have the puck. Not sure if that applies specifically, but always good to keep in mind.

stereax

Quote from: Bluelightning on Today at 12:25:58 PMMy mind keeps coming back to Charlie Major. I don't think he has a single point yet. His +\- is team worst -5 (and he's on power play, which doesn't mean anything with Cornell).
    To me, when he is out there....there is no chemistry with anyone. If he keeps puck and gets deep, everyone else just watches. If he passes it off, everyone seems like they dont know what to do.
  I'm not a hockey expert. But I know we need Charlie to be very good. He has as much skill offensively as almost anyone on team (handling, passing, shooting)...but we aren't seeing results. We need him to be a leader both on the stat sheet and in locker room. He's a junior with a ton of experience here at Cornell. We need him to at least take control and be the leader of the 2nd line. If we don't start to get goals when he is on the ice, we won't have much success. Too much of the load is on Walsh line
So I'm looking through old line charts and I'm noticing something:

Major's most effective games last year were when he was paired with Walsh or Castagna. He was shifted down the lineup later in the year in part due to the emergences of guys like Cato and DiGiulian - the disastrous "Major at center" experiments that I bemoaned at length.

My suspicion is, despite the hero puck antics, Major can't actually drive his own line. And Casey and crew expect him to be doing that, which is what's causing the friction. Giving him the second-most TOI for forwards, only behind Walsh, isn't helping: 20:17, 22:23, 21:39, 17:03, 19:32, 14:53. And no points to show for it.

Maybe try 12-14-09 and see if that gets Charlie out of his funk. If not, it's gonna be a long year for him.

(Tbh I prefer having 10-14-12 as the top line, just because the Kraft-Walsh chemistry is excellent.)

(Corollary: Long spent most of his time last year stapled to specifically Castagna's wing. He's also going to be adjusting to playing wing to guys who aren't Castagna. He's a -4 right now, second-worst on the team, but at least he's got a positive CHIP and looks like he's being effective out there.)

Would love to see isolated CHIP per game stats and the like. With-or-without-you analyses. XGF% for specific players, per game, and all. (Am I a stats nerd? Fuck, I don't want to be a stats nerd.)
Law '27, Section C denizen, liveblogging from Lynah!
it's ster-e-ax, like stereo

stereax

Quote from: The Rancor on Today at 01:34:15 PM
Quote from: stereax on Today at 11:53:44 AM
Quote from: Snowball on Today at 11:15:48 AMThere was a fair amount of play to like in this game: Rousseau was consistent and had some marvelous saves. There was good play form many: Cato of course, Zad, Pirtle, Fegaras, Fisher, Ashton and Gorski, imho. Of the new guys I thought that Randle and Gardner were impressive, and I love the energy of Coco.

Something's off with Walshy and face-offs: he was 8 for 22 last night, and was 16 of 34 the night before. That alone had a big impact on the weekend. Upper body injury?

Consider this counterfactual: one of Walshy's shots goes in, we beat Yale, and everyone walks away feeling a little better about themselves.

Would that actually have been a good thing? I don't think so. We'd be talking about a win instead of confronting the real problems staring this team in the face. Sometimes a loss like this, one that stings for an entire weekend, is exactly what a team needs. Better to have the wheels come off the early in the season than to keep papering over the cracks. This sh— needs to get fixed, and it needs to get fixed now.

Casey's a great coach, he can get this done, I am looking forward to it.
Personally, I wouldn't have felt good about a win unless it was, as I mentioned previously, an "ass-blasting" of the highest order. Winning, say, 2-1 would have been nice for my mental health, sure, but it would mean we barely edged Yale, one of the worst teams in the ECAC. If we showed up and put down 5 or 6, after that miserable Brown outing, that would have shown me that the team saw what happened the night before and said "fuck that, THAT'S not happening again", put their big boy skates on, and demolished the team playing against them. We had a good first period against Yale, and then just petered out.

Sometimes a change in net can wake a room right the fuck up. Last year, the guys played way better in front of Keopple, even if he was a worse goaltender. Maybe let Rousseau sit a game, put Roest in, see what you have there and send a message.

Agreed with your assessment that a lot of the guys individually looked good. Glad to see Pirtle back in the lineup, he always provides a spark. The freshmen have been overall quite good as well.

In re faceoffs - there are new faceoff rules league-wide. I assume that's part of it. Also, having Walshy take 34 faceoffs on a night is probably part of the issue.

Anyways. It feels like the bulk of the issue is with the forward corps - the defense has been great overall and the goalie hasn't been the problem, either. We need scoring now, and for these forward lines to click. Cato, Z, and Kraft can't be all of our scoring.

Casey will figure it out.

Re: Goaltending. You can't (or shouldn't) sit the goaltender, who came here to be a starter- much like he who shant be named- if he's performing as needed just to send a message to the rest of the team. I get what you are saying: "Anyone can sit, even him" but the next thing that happens is a call to his player agent to type up a portal letter. If he was giving up 5 goals on 10 shots and getting pulled in the 2nd, maybe. But as most of us, and Casey have said: it's the offense.

Also, and I might be misremembering a Schefer quote, but they can't score if we have the puck. Not sure if that applies specifically, but always good to keep in mind.
Yea, you're probably right about that one, we don't need another portaling goalie 😅

The thing about Rousseau is he is a League Average Goaltender. Which is fine for Cornell - we're not generally a super leaky team! But as a corollary to that, he's generally not going to be stealing games for you. (That being said, letting in like 0.5 goals more than expected per game has been adding up and he's at -3.07 on the year, good for 108th of 133 on the list at CHN. Where Courns was letting in 1 goal a game in the fall last year, Rous is letting in 2. Still has a positive CHIP in the same range as Spunar (NoDak) and Smith (P) though.)
Law '27, Section C denizen, liveblogging from Lynah!
it's ster-e-ax, like stereo

BearLover

I haven't read all the above posts but the fact scoring has been trash has no bearing on the goaltending. They are independent. It can be true both that the scoring has been a disaster and that the goaltending has been bad. Together, that makes for an awful team.

Chris H82

Quote from: stereax on Today at 02:03:16 PM....
(Am I a stats nerd? Fuck, I don't want to be a stats nerd.)

Me thinks you've answered your own question. ;D

Keep at it - interesting stuff.
"What... is your favorite color?"  "Blue. No, yel--auuuuugh!"

stereax

Quote from: Chris H82 on Today at 03:11:49 PM
Quote from: stereax on Today at 02:03:16 PM....
(Am I a stats nerd? Fuck, I don't want to be a stats nerd.)

Me thinks you've answered your own question. ;D

Keep at it - interesting stuff.



Haha, I think most of the forums don't appreciate the statistics pulls 😅
Doesn't help that college hockey doesn't have a ton of sources for stats, and the ones that exist tend to be very obfuscated as to how they get the stats/how those stats are calculated.
But - I trudge along, nevertheless.

In re goaltending: goaltending has been decidedly average. The main issue is getting pucks in the net. If goaltending remains bad once scoring increases, then that's the next thing to work on - but getting 2 GA a game, this team should be able to outscore the likes of (checks notes) SHU, Brown, and Yale.
Law '27, Section C denizen, liveblogging from Lynah!
it's ster-e-ax, like stereo

BearLover

Quote from: stereax on Today at 02:16:43 PM
Quote from: The Rancor on Today at 01:34:15 PM
Quote from: stereax on Today at 11:53:44 AM
Quote from: Snowball on Today at 11:15:48 AMThere was a fair amount of play to like in this game: Rousseau was consistent and had some marvelous saves. There was good play form many: Cato of course, Zad, Pirtle, Fegaras, Fisher, Ashton and Gorski, imho. Of the new guys I thought that Randle and Gardner were impressive, and I love the energy of Coco.

Something's off with Walshy and face-offs: he was 8 for 22 last night, and was 16 of 34 the night before. That alone had a big impact on the weekend. Upper body injury?

Consider this counterfactual: one of Walshy's shots goes in, we beat Yale, and everyone walks away feeling a little better about themselves.

Would that actually have been a good thing? I don't think so. We'd be talking about a win instead of confronting the real problems staring this team in the face. Sometimes a loss like this, one that stings for an entire weekend, is exactly what a team needs. Better to have the wheels come off the early in the season than to keep papering over the cracks. This sh— needs to get fixed, and it needs to get fixed now.

Casey's a great coach, he can get this done, I am looking forward to it.
Personally, I wouldn't have felt good about a win unless it was, as I mentioned previously, an "ass-blasting" of the highest order. Winning, say, 2-1 would have been nice for my mental health, sure, but it would mean we barely edged Yale, one of the worst teams in the ECAC. If we showed up and put down 5 or 6, after that miserable Brown outing, that would have shown me that the team saw what happened the night before and said "fuck that, THAT'S not happening again", put their big boy skates on, and demolished the team playing against them. We had a good first period against Yale, and then just petered out.

Sometimes a change in net can wake a room right the fuck up. Last year, the guys played way better in front of Keopple, even if he was a worse goaltender. Maybe let Rousseau sit a game, put Roest in, see what you have there and send a message.

Agreed with your assessment that a lot of the guys individually looked good. Glad to see Pirtle back in the lineup, he always provides a spark. The freshmen have been overall quite good as well.

In re faceoffs - there are new faceoff rules league-wide. I assume that's part of it. Also, having Walshy take 34 faceoffs on a night is probably part of the issue.

Anyways. It feels like the bulk of the issue is with the forward corps - the defense has been great overall and the goalie hasn't been the problem, either. We need scoring now, and for these forward lines to click. Cato, Z, and Kraft can't be all of our scoring.

Casey will figure it out.

Re: Goaltending. You can't (or shouldn't) sit the goaltender, who came here to be a starter- much like he who shant be named- if he's performing as needed just to send a message to the rest of the team. I get what you are saying: "Anyone can sit, even him" but the next thing that happens is a call to his player agent to type up a portal letter. If he was giving up 5 goals on 10 shots and getting pulled in the 2nd, maybe. But as most of us, and Casey have said: it's the offense.

Also, and I might be misremembering a Schefer quote, but they can't score if we have the puck. Not sure if that applies specifically, but always good to keep in mind.
Yea, you're probably right about that one, we don't need another portaling goalie 😅

The thing about Rousseau is he is a League Average Goaltender. Which is fine for Cornell - we're not generally a super leaky team! But as a corollary to that, he's generally not going to be stealing games for you. (That being said, letting in like 0.5 goals more than expected per game has been adding up and he's at -3.07 on the year, good for 108th of 133 on the list at CHN. Where Courns was letting in 1 goal a game in the fall last year, Rous is letting in 2. Still has a positive CHIP in the same range as Spunar (NoDak) and Smith (P) though.)
I don't think CHIP is a real stat. Goals saved above expected is probably the best we can do *if* the expected goal statistic is properly calibrated, which for college hockey it sounds like it isn't because it doesn't factor in type of shot, speed of shot, etc. (as compared to the NHL where the stat factors in all this and more). So I'm afraid save % might be the best publicly available stat we have to evaluate college goalies. From that perspective we have been a lot worse the national average. (FWIW, if you look at goals saved above expected we've been similarly bad.) Hoping this turns around, obviously.