ECAC All-Decade Team?

[pfibiger]

From the INCH weekly ECAC column:

"ECAC Hockey will soon announce its all-decade team spanning the seasons 1999-2000 through 2008-09. The list of candidates was impressive to peruse and brought back memories of many of the league's greatest players over the last 10 years. A panel of coaches, media and sports information directors voted on the nominees. Look for that to be announced in the near future. And how do you pick just two goalies from a list that includes the likes of Danis, LeNeveu, Kalemba, Dekanich, McKee, Grumet-Morris and Scrivens?"

My attempt at putting together these teams:

F: Lee Stempniak
F: Dominic Moore
F: Tyler Burton
D: Reid Cashman
D: Doug Murray
G: David LeNeveu

F: Matt Moulson
F: Marc Cavosie
F: T.J. Trevelyan
D: Mark McRae
D: Noah Welch
G: Yann Danis

Honorable Mention: Matt Murley, David McKee, Mike Moore, David McIntyre, Chris Higgins, Nick Dodge.

[Trotsky]

That's a pretty good team.

Some other guys who come to mind:

Andy McDonald
Jeff Hamilton
David Jones
Lee Jubinville
Sean Backman
Marc Arcobello

[Lowell '99]

Not even an honorable mention for Stephen Baby?

[WillCMJr]

I would at least consider Vesce!  Murray to me should be a lock for 1st team!

I think Lenny is a bad candidate because of the shortness of his career, not his greatness of course.

And I wouldn't vote for McKee.

Scrivens gets my honorable mention.  While not the best, his longevity and statistical consistency over the past 3 years have been awesome.

[Josh '99]

I would at least consider Vesce!  Murray to me should be a lock for 1st team!

I think Lenny is a bad candidate because of the shortness of his career, not his greatness of course.

And I wouldn't vote for McKee.

Scrivens gets my honorable mention.  While not the best, his longevity and statistical consistency over the past 3 years have been awesome.

Will raises a fair point - as great as Lenny and McKee were, maybe guys who stayed around and played at a high level for four years (Scrivens, Kalemba, Silverthorn, Richards; Mike Walsh omitted intentionally because he sucked).  

I wonder whether they might separately honor/recognize/(whatever the proper word is) the late Nathan Marsters (RPI '04), whose too-soon passing still feels a bit surreal.  Marsters was, at the beginning of the 2003-04 hockey season, the only active goalie to have won a game at Lynah, which I thought was an interesting trivia note at the time.  He also (unbeknownst to many) did the Dryden pose more than once during RPI games at Lynah, which I probably thought was obnoxious at the time but (in hindsight) probably was an homage as much as anything else.

[ugarte]

I think Lenny is a bad candidate because of the shortness of his career, not his greatness of course....

Will raises a fair point - as great as Lenny and McKee were, maybe guys who stayed around and played at a high level for four years (Scrivens, Kalemba, Silverthorn, Richards; Mike Walsh omitted intentionally because he sucked).  ...

I think it would be a shame to eliminate a guy from the all-ECAC team on the grounds that he was too good for the ECAC (or college hockey at all).

[Trotsky]

I think it would be a shame to eliminate a guy from the all-ECAC team on the grounds that he was too good for the ECAC (or college hockey at all).

Question is, is it the best players or the players who made the greatest contribution to their college team?  I tend to agree with you -- hard to not pick Paul Kariya for the 90's all-decade Hockey East team, even if he only played one year.

[French Rage]

Just make it the entire 2002-2003 starting lineup.

[Give My Regards]

Just for the sake of completeness, here are the previous ECAC(H) All-Decade teams.  There doesn't appear to be one for the 1960's, perhaps in part because ECAC Hockey was kind of a loose association of teams until the 1964-65 season.


ECAC All-Decade Team – 1970's

First team:

F Joe Cavanagh, Harvard (1968-71)
F Rick Meagher, Boston University (1973-77)
F Lance Nethery, Cornell (1975-79)
D Bill Blackwood, Clarkson (1974-78)
D Ron Wilson, Providence (1973-77)
G Bruce Bullock, Clarkson (1967-71)

Second team:

F Gordie Clark, New Hampshire (1970-74)
F Mike Eruzione, Boston University (1973-77)
F Joe Mullen, Boston College (1975-79)
F Dave Taylor, Clarkson (1973-77)
D Peter Brown, Boston University (1972-76)
D Vic Stanfield, Boston University (1971-75)
G Jim Craig, Boston University (1975-79)
G Brian Shields, Clarkson (1973-77)


ECAC All-Decade Team – 1980's
(no first- or second-team designations)

F Steve Cruickshank, Clarkson (1978-82)
F Scott Fusco, Harvard (1982-86)
F Pete Lappin, St. Lawrence (1984-88)
F Lane MacDonald, Harvard (1985-89)
F Joe Nieuwendyk, Cornell (1984-87)
F Adam Oates, RPI (1981-85)
D Dave Fretz, Clarkson (1981-85)
D Mark Fusco, Harvard (1979-83)
D Ed Small, Clarkson (1977-81)
D Randy Velischek, Providence (1979-83)
G Cleon Daskalakis, Boston University (1980-84)
G Don Sylvestri, Clarkson (1981-85)


ECAC All-Decade Team – 1990's

First team:

F Joe Juneau, RPI (1987-91)
F Martin St. Louis, Vermont (1993-97)
F Todd White, Clarkson (1993-97)
D Ray Giroux, Yale (1994-98)
D Brian Mueller, Clarkson (1991-95)
G Tim Thomas, Vermont (1993-97)

Second team:

F Peter Ciavaglia, Harvard (1987-91)
F Ted Drury, Harvard (1989-93)
F Mike Harder, Colgate (1993-97)
F Eric Perrin, Vermont (1993-97)
D Dan Laperriere, St. Lawrence (1988-92)
D Sean McCann, Harvard (1990-94)
G Trevor Koenig, Union (1994-98)

[mikek]

Player breakdown by team:

Clarkson - 10
Sucks - 7
BU - 6
Vermont - 3
Cornell - 2
SLU - 2
RPI - 2
Providence - 2
Yale - 1
Union - 1
Colgate - 1
BC - 1
UNH - 1

Hopefully we'll be able to move up this list after this past decade is announced

[Trotsky]

Hopefully we'll be able to move up this list after this past decade is announced

Considering Cornell's W-L dominance of the decade, the tabulation of ECAC First Team by team for the years 2000-09 is pretty surprising:

11 St. Lawrence
8 Clarkson
7 Cornell
7 Dartmouth
6 Colgate
5 Harvard
4 RPI
4 Princeton
3 Yale
2 Quinnipiac
1 Brown
1 Union
1 Vermont

[Al DeFlorio]

Player breakdown by team:

Clarkson - 10
Sucks - 7
BU - 6
Vermont - 3
Cornell - 2
SLU - 2
RPI - 2
Providence - 2
Yale - 1
Union - 1
Colgate - 1
BC - 1
UNH - 1

Hopefully we'll be able to move up this list after this past decade is announced

Makes you wonder how Cornell can have twice as many Whitelaws as Clarkson since 1970.

[French Rage]

Player breakdown by team:

Clarkson - 10
Sucks - 7
BU - 6
Vermont - 3
Cornell - 2
SLU - 2
RPI - 2
Providence - 2
Yale - 1
Union - 1
Colgate - 1
BC - 1
UNH - 1

Hopefully we'll be able to move up this list after this past decade is announced

Makes you wonder how Cornell can have twice as many Whitelaws as Clarkson since 1970.

Darnedest thing about team sports.

[KeithK]

Player breakdown by team:

Clarkson - 10
Sucks - 7
BU - 6
Vermont - 3
Cornell - 2
SLU - 2
RPI - 2
Providence - 2
Yale - 1
Union - 1
Colgate - 1
BC - 1
UNH - 1

Hopefully we'll be able to move up this list after this past decade is announced

Makes you wonder how Cornell can have twice as many Whitelaws as Clarkson since 1970.

Darnedest thing about team sports.

It's the system.

[Tom Tone]

From http://cornellbigred.com/news/2010/3/2/MICE_0302101658.aspx

All-ECAC Hockey Teams
First Team
F - Chase Polacek, Rensselaer
F - Broc Little, Yale
F - Sean Backman, Yale
D - Mike Schreiber, Union
D - Brendon Nash, Cornell
G - Ben Scrivens, Cornell

Second Team
F - Mario Valery-Trabucco, Union
F - David McIntyre, Colgate
F - Colin Greening, Cornell
D - Tom Dignard, Yale
D - Taylor Fedun, Princeton
G - Allen York, Rensselaer

Third-Team
F - Riley Nash, Cornell
F - Aaron Volpatti, Brown
F - Travis Vermeulen, St. Lawrence
D - Derek Keller, St. Lawrence
D - Evan Stephens, Dartmouth
G - Keith Kinkaid, Union

All-Newcomer Team
F - Jerry D'Amigo, Rensselaer
F - Brandon Pirri, Rensselaer
F - Louis Leblanc, Harvard
D - George Hughes, St. Lawrence
D - Nick D'Agostino, Cornell
G - Keith Kinkaid, Union