All-time Cornell team

[billhoward]

Ken Dryden is the goalie and Ned Harkness is the coach. So that leaves two defensemen and three forwards. Plus second team and honorable mention. And special teams like power play, penalty kill, offensive defenseman (sorry, nominations closed;  that was filled in 1970 in the third period of the title game), and the guy you want to take a penalty shot or have a man-short breakaway. (Say, have we had any breakaways the last two years? If so, how come nobody scored?)

[O.S.B.]

yeah i think mcrae had one this season and the goalie got it with his stick

[Greg Berge]

How about the entire 1967 team?  ;-)

Seriously, if I had to name an all-time squad, I would name two: a "classic" team and a "modern era" team.  The program was reestablished in 1959; a convenient midpoint is the end of the Bertrand era (1982).  So, starting 6's in classic and modern keys:


G - Ken Dryden
D - Dan Lodboa
D - Harry Orr
F - Doug Ferguson
F - Pete Tufford
F - Lance Nethery
Coach - Ned Harkness


G - Dave LeNeveu
D - Dan Ratushny
D - Doug Murray
F - Joe Nieuwendyk
F - Doug Derraugh
F - Brad Chartrand
Coach - Mike Schafer

[ugarte]

You wouldn't put Nieuwendyk on the all-time team?

[Killer]

It's too late to give this thought it requires, but I'll throw in one:

Penalty shot - Carlo "The Magician" Ugolini

[billhoward]

Carlo Ugolini ('73) was a great player who felt the refs missed a lot of apparent second assists that should have gone to, ah, Carlo. I believe his line was, "I was pimped, ref."

He was also the kind of guy you wanted on the ice in the last two minutes with Cornell down a goal.

Maybe there should be a Cornelll all-time under-5-foot-8 team and Carlo deserves a spot there, too.

[Greg Berge]

For penalty kill, I want to see Randy MacFarlane.

To take a key faceoff late in the game, I'd elect either Vesce or Karl Williams.

[R. Stott]

I would put Nieuwendyke on the first team over Tufford and make Dadswell the second team goaltender.

I'd  go with Chartrand on the faceoff.

[Killer]

Anyone remember Carlo taking a penalty shot where the opposing coach pulled the goalie and inserted a defenseman?  I seem to recall the guy came out to challenge, Carlo faked him out of his shorts, then paused in front of the empty net to give the guy a look before he put the puck in.

(I don't think I dreamed this, but then, in my old age...LOL)

[Al DeFlorio]

[Q]R. Stott Wrote:

 I would put Nieuwendyke on the first team over Tufford and make Dadswell the second team goaltender.

I'd  go with Chartrand on the faceoff.[/q]

I don't think Greg intended there to be a "first" team and a "second" team.  I read it that he named two teams from two different eras, with no attempt at a ranking of one versus the other.  IMO, a very reasonable way to go about doing it.

[Al DeFlorio]

[Q]Killer Wrote:

 Anyone remember Carlo taking a penalty shot where the opposing coach pulled the goalie and inserted a defenseman? [/q]
Geez, I didn't think Mark Morris was around in those days.;-)

[ugarte]

[Q]Al DeFlorio Wrote:

 [Q2]R. Stott Wrote:

 I would put Nieuwendyke on the first team over Tufford and make Dadswell the second team goaltender.

I'd  go with Chartrand on the faceoff.[/Q]
I don't think Greg intended there to be a "first" team and a "second" team.  I read it that he named two teams from two different eras, with no attempt at a ranking of one versus the other.  IMO, a very reasonable way to go about doing it.[/q]
I think that's true also, but the way I read his chart there was an all-time team and a modern-era team.  I was curious as to whether Greg intended them to be mutually exclusive or if Nieuwendyk qualified for his all-time team but didn't make the (very high) cut.

[Al DeFlorio]

I think Greg named one team from the Patten/Harkness/Bertrand era and one from the Reycroft/McCutcheon/Schafer era, with no intent to rank players from one era vis-a-vis the other.

Discussions of Tufford vs. Brian Cornell or LeNeveu vs. Dadswell are certainly appropriate within that context.

[Killer]

Did he try that too?  Any better results?

I'm probably mistaken, but I think that when Carlo faced that defenseman, we were playing Brown.  (Of course, I seem to recall a lot of weird stuff from when we played Brown.  Maybe...)  Anyone know?

[Al DeFlorio]

[Q]Killer Wrote:

 Did he try that too?  Any better results?

I'm probably mistaken, but I think that when Carlo faced that defenseman, we were playing Brown.  (Of course, I seem to recall a lot of weird stuff from when we played Brown.  Maybe...)  Anyone know?[/q]

Bob, I have no idea if Morris ever tried such a move, but he not infrequently made...um...unconventional tactics with his goalies.