Cornell Soccer 2026

Started by chimpfood, July 07, 2026, 12:54:54 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

scoop85

USA Today pegs us for the 16th seed and final bye and predicts we'd face the Marshall-Lehigh winner in the 2nd round. If seeding held we'd then play #1 Georgetown in the 3rd round. But we'll know where we stand by tomorrow afternoon.

chimpfood

Absolute horseshit, we get a 6 seed from 12 in the rpi. The committee continuously just rewards strength of schedule regardless of how visibly bad a team is, I mean Syracuse made the tournament this year at .500 and if anyone has watched them play they are clearly not a good team, just because they play in a good conference and lose to good teams does not mean they're good. Now we have to play a very solid fairleigh Dickinson side in the first round and then travel to Rutgers on short rest. Just awful from the committee, but at the same time we keep setting ourselves up for this by having a weak schedule every year despite seeing over and over again that that's the only thing the committee cares about.

ugarte

Quote from: chimpfood on November 16, 2026, 01:54:45 PMAbsolute horseshit, we get a 6 seed from 12 in the rpi. The committee continuously just rewards strength of schedule regardless of how visibly bad a team is, I mean Syracuse made the tournament this year at .500 and if anyone has watched them play they are clearly not a good team, just because they play in a good conference and lose to good teams does not mean they're good. Now we have to play a very solid fairleigh Dickinson side in the first round and then travel to Rutgers on short rest. Just awful from the committee, but at the same time we keep setting ourselves up for this by having a weak schedule every year despite seeing over and over again that that's the only thing the committee cares about.
I will be honest: I do not hate this result. I don't even think it's particularly unfair.

1) 0-1  @Colgate (161) - a shande by any definition despite how tilted the field was based on shots and possession. Nobody looks at that. Colgate closed their season with a 4-0 loss to Army, a team ranked even lower (197) than Colgate.

2) 1-1 @Yale (107) - despite making the ILT, Yale was the second-lowest ranked team in the Ivies.

3) We have no wins over tournament teams. Zero. We have a pair of competitive losses - @Akron (2; 1 seed) and @Pitt (9; 2 seed) but despite our SOS, that's what we have to show for it. Our best non-Ivy win is UCSB (39) who missed the field. As for the Ivies, we were in a ...

4) Weak Conference - The Ivies are a one bid conference. The committee did not buy Princeton (36) or Penn (43) as credible at-large teams. Penn's only decent win? Princeton. Princeton had wins over tournament teams @Bryant (23: unseeded) and Portland (26; 6 seed) but such bad results (L @Dartmouth (85); L @Brown (89); T Villanova (117); T @Columbia (119)) and a 7th place conference finish. I understand why they were left out.

5) In every other context we talk about how RPI is dumb and under-explanatory so while I think it's cool that we finished at 12, I'm not taking that as gospel. We pulled some rabbits out of hats to get where we ended up.

Finally, as it stands, we still get a home game and I don't think it's really a toss-up. We can lose but go in as a heavy favorite. For whatever RPI is worth, FDU (71) is behind P/P and ahead of the rest of the Ivies but imo they are further removed from their RPI than the committee thought we were. They have a gaudy 13-3 record but look at  how it was built. They upset LIU (135) to make the tournament but lost to them 3-0 during the regular season. They lost 3-1 to Penn at home. There's nothing there to make you flinch.

If we win that home game, we do have to go on the road to face Rutgers (11). Rutgers is a good but beatable team and more or less a reasonable second round opponent for us (and us for them) once you step away from RPI. R16 would probably be yet another match @Pitt... but maybe not! Maybe we get to host San Diego or Grand Canyon and make those guys buy winter coats for the flight.

It's been a good season and I'm disappointed but OK with this result. Game on, Knights. Thursday at 7pm.

scoop85

Quote from: ugarte on November 16, 2026, 03:07:28 PM
Quote from: chimpfood on November 16, 2026, 01:54:45 PMAbsolute horseshit, we get a 6 seed from 12 in the rpi. The committee continuously just rewards strength of schedule regardless of how visibly bad a team is, I mean Syracuse made the tournament this year at .500 and if anyone has watched them play they are clearly not a good team, just because they play in a good conference and lose to good teams does not mean they're good. Now we have to play a very solid fairleigh Dickinson side in the first round and then travel to Rutgers on short rest. Just awful from the committee, but at the same time we keep setting ourselves up for this by having a weak schedule every year despite seeing over and over again that that's the only thing the committee cares about.
I will be honest: I do not hate this result. I don't even think it's particularly unfair.

1) 0-1  @Colgate (161) - a shande by any definition despite how tilted the field was based on shots and possession. Nobody looks at that. Colgate closed their season with a 4-0 loss to Army, a team ranked even lower (197) than Colgate.

2) 1-1 @Yale (107) - despite making the ILT, Yale was the second-lowest ranked team in the Ivies.

3) We have no wins over tournament teams. Zero. We have a pair of competitive losses - @Akron (2; 1 seed) and @Pitt (9; 2 seed) but despite our SOS, that's what we have to show for it. Our best non-Ivy win is UCSB (39) who missed the field. As for the Ivies, we were in a ...

4) Weak Conference - The Ivies are a one bid conference. The committee did not buy Princeton (36) or Penn (43) as credible at-large teams. Penn's only decent win? Princeton. Princeton had wins over tournament teams @Bryant (23: unseeded) and Portland (26; 6 seed) but such bad results (L @Dartmouth (85); L @Brown (89); T Villanova (117); T @Columbia (119)) and a 7th place conference finish. I understand why they were left out.

5) In every other context we talk about how RPI is dumb and under-explanatory so while I think it's cool that we finished at 12, I'm not taking that as gospel. We pulled some rabbits out of hats to get where we ended up.

Finally, as it stands, we still get a home game and I don't think it's really a toss-up. We can lose but go in as a heavy favorite. For whatever RPI is worth, FDU (71) is behind P/P and ahead of the rest of the Ivies but imo they are further removed from their RPI than the committee thought we were. They have a gaudy 13-3 record but look at  how it was built. They upset LIU (135) to make the tournament but lost to them 3-0 during the regular season. They lost 3-1 to Penn at home. There's nothing there to make you flinch.

If we win that home game, we do have to go on the road to face Rutgers (11). Rutgers is a good but beatable team and more or less a reasonable second round opponent for us (and us for them) once you step away from RPI. R16 would probably be yet another match @Pitt... but maybe not! Maybe we get to host San Diego or Grand Canyon and make those guys buy winter coats for the flight.

It's been a good season and I'm disappointed but OK with this result. Game on, Knights. Thursday at 7pm.

When I first saw we didn't get a bye I was ticked off, but your more sober analysis seems pretty spot-on to me. The Ivies were weaker than normal this year, and the fact we didn't beat a single tournament team certainly gives the committee reasonable cover for how we were treated. I think 2 wins is an attainable goal given the bracket.

arugula

Everyone is burying the lede here. Cornell's men's hockey head coach is named Casey Jones and its men's soccer head coach is named John Smith. Are these men in witness protection?

Jeff Hopkins '82

Quote from: arugula on November 16, 2026, 05:31:24 PMEveryone is burying the lede here. Cornell's men's hockey head coach is named Casey Jones and its men's soccer head coach is named John Smith. Are these men in witness protection?

If the next football coach is named Sam Francisco, I'll start to think it's an alien invasion.

CU2007

Quote from: Jeff Hopkins '82 on November 16, 2026, 06:26:15 PM
Quote from: arugula on November 16, 2026, 05:31:24 PMEveryone is burying the lede here. Cornell's men's hockey head coach is named Casey Jones and its men's soccer head coach is named John Smith. Are these men in witness protection?

If the next football coach is named Sam Francisco, I'll start to think it's an alien invasion.

Or Todd Bonzalez. IYKYK

chimpfood

The entire point of the RPI is to adjust for strength of schedule and the college soccer RPI does so HEAVILY. It's ridiculous to act like the cut line of Q1 or teams that made the tournament separates good teams from terrible teams. We have four wins over teams that barely missed the tournament. With the way the committee seeded this year we would've had a better seed if we lost to Penn in the final, because then we would've had a win over a tournament team.

ugarte

Quote from: chimpfood on November 17, 2026, 12:27:17 AMThe entire point of the RPI is to adjust for strength of schedule and the college soccer RPI does so HEAVILY. It's ridiculous to act like the cut line of Q1 or teams that made the tournament separates good teams from terrible teams. We have four wins over teams that barely missed the tournament. With the way the committee seeded this year we would've had a better seed if we lost to Penn in the final, because then we would've had a win over a tournament team.
once again, since we know RPI sucks - primitive statistical analysis - who cares?

BearLover

Do we know RPI sucks? Do we know a better option? If so, is the committee using that better option? If they're not, they should just stick to RPI. The judgments of humans on a committee trying to ascertain SOS is almost certainly less accurate than RPI.

ugarte

Quote from: BearLover on November 17, 2026, 01:26:18 AMDo we know RPI sucks? Do we know a better option?
The ELO/KRACH/KenPom are generally understood to be better, no? I don't know if anyone publishes that for college soccer, i only know that the nerds have been telling me (a dork) for years that RPI is a crude way of incorporating SOS (but a useful check on the eye test and various biases).

BearLover

Quote from: ugarte on November 17, 2026, 10:59:04 AM
Quote from: BearLover on November 17, 2026, 01:26:18 AMDo we know RPI sucks? Do we know a better option?
The ELO/KRACH/KenPom are generally understood to be better, no? I don't know if anyone publishes that for college soccer, i only know that the nerds have been telling me (a dork) for years that RPI is a crude way of incorporating SOS (but a useful check on the eye test and various biases).
Well, as far as I can tell, those computer formulas are better for other sports, but I don't know enough about soccer. (Each sport has its intricacies regarding whether teams play enough out of conference games to properly judge SOS.) I am sure there are computer formulas superior to RPI. My issue here is that (1) I highly doubt the humans seeding the NCAA soccer tournament looked at other computer formulas and (2) even if they did, you can't have humans cherrypicking whichever stats or formulas they like to justify seeding. You can find stats and formulas to justify just about anything. Unless you stick to one consistent formula, you end up with an arbitrary process riddled with error. As I say, though, I doubt the committee was looking at any formula at all. Rather, they were looking at arbitrary bullshit like "tier 1 wins"/"tier 4 losses." None of this makes any sense. It's nonsensical to treat beating the best team in the country and losing to the 60th best team any differently than the reverse. I absolutely don't trust humans on the committee to do a better job ranking teams than even a rudimentary formula like RPI.