Top 50 Players in ECAC Hockey

[Josh '99]

I think if Willie Mitchell makes it on the list I'll have to do something drastic.

I had the same thought.  Fuck that guy.

[KeithK]

I think if Willie Mitchell makes it on the list I'll have to do something drastic.

I had the same thought.  Fuck that guy.

Better not or else you might get syphilis.

[Jim Hyla]

Nieuwendyk makes the second listing.

[Al DeFlorio]

Nieuwendyk makes the second listing.

Very puzzling list.  Andy McDonald was a fine player but named in the second five over Dave Taylor?  Or Martin St. Louis?  Huh?  And how does a second-team all-decade forward make it before all the first-team forwards (Hamilton, Stempniak, and Trevelyan; Moulson was 2nd team along with McDonald and Dom Moore) of that decade make it?

[Trotsky]

Nieuwendyk makes the second listing.

Very puzzling list.  Andy McDonald was a fine player but named in the second five over Dave Taylor?  Or Martin St. Louis?  Huh?  And how does a second-team all-decade forward make it before all the first-team forwards (Hamilton, Stempniak, and Trevelyan; Moulson was 2nd team along with McDonald and Dom Moore) of that decade make it?

Is there any order to the announcements?  I was under the impression that The Fifty are to be considered on the same level.

[Jim Hyla]

Nieuwendyk makes the second listing.

Very puzzling list.  Andy McDonald was a fine player but named in the second five over Dave Taylor?  Or Martin St. Louis?  Huh?  And how does a second-team all-decade forward make it before all the first-team forwards (Hamilton, Stempniak, and Trevelyan; Moulson was 2nd team along with McDonald and Dom Moore) of that decade make it?

Is there any order to the announcements?  I was under the impression that The Fifty are to be considered on the same level.

That's  the way I thought about it, too.

[Al DeFlorio]

Nieuwendyk makes the second listing.

Very puzzling list.  Andy McDonald was a fine player but named in the second five over Dave Taylor?  Or Martin St. Louis?  Huh?  And how does a second-team all-decade forward make it before all the first-team forwards (Hamilton, Stempniak, and Trevelyan; Moulson was 2nd team along with McDonald and Dom Moore) of that decade make it?

Is there any order to the announcements?  I was under the impression that The Fifty are to be considered on the same level.

That's  the way I thought about it, too.

OK.  We'll see if Stempniak, Hamilton, and Trevelyan are in the remaining 40.

[KeithK]

Nieuwendyk makes the second listing.

Very puzzling list.  Andy McDonald was a fine player but named in the second five over Dave Taylor?  Or Martin St. Louis?  Huh?  And how does a second-team all-decade forward make it before all the first-team forwards (Hamilton, Stempniak, and Trevelyan; Moulson was 2nd team along with McDonald and Dom Moore) of that decade make it?

Is there any order to the announcements?  I was under the impression that The Fifty are to be considered on the same level.

That's  the way I thought about it, too.

OK.  We'll see if Stempniak, Hamilton, and Trevelyan are in the remaining 40.

There's always the chance that it's just different people picking this set of players to honor.  The All-Decade teams aren't ensconced in ECAC canonical law or anything. :-)

[nshapiro]

What about Ratushny or UVM's Kirk McCaskill?

[ursusminor]

Third group http://www.ecachockey.com/men/2010-11/50th_Anniversary/20100812_Top_50_Segment_3 Joe Cavanagh, Yann Danis, Dave Fretz, Dan Laperriere, and Martin St. Louis.

[ftyuv]

Tim Thomas of UVM? We here in Boston have learned to love him.

[Josh '99]

Third group http://www.ecachockey.com/men/2010-11/50th_Anniversary/20100812_Top_50_Segment_3 Joe Cavanagh, Yann Danis, Dave Fretz, Dan Laperriere, and Martin St. Louis.

Because this can never be mocked enough:

http://web.archive.org/web/20050429015130/brownbears.collegesports.com/yanndanis/

[Trotsky]

Third group http://www.ecachockey.com/men/2010-11/50th_Anniversary/20100812_Top_50_Segment_3 Joe Cavanagh, Yann Danis, Dave Fretz, Dan Laperriere, and Martin St. Louis.

Because this can never be mocked enough:

http://web.archive.org/web/20050429015130/brownbears.collegesports.com/yanndanis/

Both lame and great at the same time.  Much like:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=45TVwhQ6Cjs

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O5YjPteCPLo

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K9cYcRotufU

[RatushnyFan]

They don't seem to tire of that Top Gun song.

[Jim Hyla]

Lance Nethery makes the next group.