Places to eat in Ithaca

[billhoward]

With all due respect to the people who enjoyed Joe's when they were in Ithaca, the first time I was unfortunate enough to end up at an Olive Garden, I thought "this reminds me of Joe's."

I enjoyed Joe's back then. I didn't this winter. I can't see it surviving on nostalgia. It has more atmosphere than Olive Garden but the food isn't that good.

I suppose it would be great to have eating / drinking places that survive for decades and even generations such as Mory's in New Haven, except it closed in 2008 or 2009, IIRC. Better to have good places to eat regardless of history. My father in law took us to a restaurant he recalled from way back when (in NJ where he grew up) except the parcel was a brand new Land Rover dealership, so he took us to another place he thought was still around. It was. We asked when he was there last. "Just before I shipped out." That would be 1944. Run by Cornell Hotelies so of course it was pretty good.

[munchkin]

Rongovian Embassy in Trumansburg, if you're willing to drive.  Big beer selection and decent food, often live music.

[gonyr]

Pizza from The Nines. (Pretty decent wings, too).

[billhoward]

Rongovian Embassy in Trumansburg, if you're willing to drive.  Big beer selection and decent food, often live music.

They're still around? Amazing. 35+ years in business.

[Dpperk29]

Antlers was great - hope it still is.  And Joe your name used to be the place in town - Joe's.  But I guess it changed ownership and isn't as good.  And don't forget popcorn at Dunbars if you only have enough money for beer.  Ithaca Bakery is great for lunch.  Moosewood is worth a try if you're open to vegetarian cuisine.  Ruloff's is a good place for a date - took my future wife there on our first date!  (she had the fajitas and liked them)

Antlers is still there, and still amazing. The Fillet Minion is well worth it.

[munchkin]

Rongovian Embassy in Trumansburg, if you're willing to drive.  Big beer selection and decent food, often live music.

They're still around? Amazing. 35+ years in business.

Whenever my mom (class of '78) would visit me, we'd go there.  She went a lot when she was in undergrad, not so popular among students these days though, I never went with anyone but her, but I always had great food and a good time.

[mnagowski]

Rongovian Embassy in Trumansburg, if you're willing to drive.  Big beer selection and decent food, often live music.

They're still around? Amazing. 35+ years in business.

Whenever my mom (class of '78) would visit me, we'd go there.  She went a lot when she was in undergrad, not so popular among students these days though, I never went with anyone but her, but I always had great food and a good time.

The Rongovian is still one of those places I need to go to. There's also apparently a good restaurant right next to it, Hazlenut Kitchen, that I need to try. Good thing it is between my house and Lynah.

[Willy '06]

This is an extremely helpful resource: http://dining.14850.com/

If you are looking to spend some serious money, check out The Heights or John Thomas. I live in downtown Chicago and eat out a lot, and those two would stand up to nearly any of the places that I've been around here.

It's too bad that you're going to miss the Farmer's market because that is also a great place to eat.

[Tom Lento]

For a good beer selection and decent food you can try the Ale House downtown. If you don't mind a bit of a drive you can get good burgers and an interesting location at the Rogue's Harbor Inn. I believe it's up on 34 along the lake. Personally, I always thought Ruloff's was overrated. It's not bad, I just don't like it as much as some of the others around these parts.

[joecct]

Evening 1

Ate dinner at the Antlers -- food was excellent.  Recommend the place to anyone coming up for reunion.

Complaint department
Staying @ the Best Western -- no ESPN in the hotel.  Room is nice, but cable offered in the room stinks.

[mnagowski]

Evening 1

Ate dinner at the Antlers -- food was excellent. Recommend the place to anyone coming up for reunion.

fr
Glad to hear. Always concerned when I make a recommendation based on an experience from five years ago.

Reunion tomorrow night! I think we're going to kick the weekend off at Glenwood Pines.

[joecct]

Further update

Monday --
Zsa Zsa's (Za Za's???) - it's across the street from Purity.  Avoid it like the plague.  Service was very very slow and the meal was not worth the price.
Purity ice cream -- 4 stars

Tuesday
Glenwood Pines -- 4 stars.  For the record I did not try for the Wall of Fame.  They also have Purity Ice Cream

Tonight
Pray for me..  The ladies want to go to the mall and shop and we'll eat @ the mall

Thursday
Plan is back to the Antlers....  Live Lobster night.

Friday
It's Cornell reunion.  This Clarkson grad is heading out of town before you start celebrating the 40th anniversary of your last NCAA championship!!!  

[Tom Lento]

Funny, I ate at Zsa Zsa's the night they opened and had the exact same experience you describe here. I'm amazed they're still around. Hope the mall food wasn't too terrible.

[joecct]

Update on last Wednesday....

Ladies decided to go to the mall in Syracuse.  The guys went to Anlters for the $12.95 prime rib special.

[Willy '06]

Zsa Zsa's was pretty good a few years ago. I wonder what happened.