ELynah Forum

General Category => Hockey => Topic started by: calgARI '07 on March 29, 2006, 01:30:56 AM

Title: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: calgARI '07 on March 29, 2006, 01:30:56 AM
He turned down an offer from Carolina to stay at Michigan for another year.  Considering he was one of the best defenseman in college hockey as a freshman, hopefully this sends a message to players around college hockey that there is a lot to gain from staying at the college level and developing.

http://www.tsn.ca/nhl/news_story/?ID=160414&hubname=nhl
Title: Re: Possible Teams That May Sign McKee
Post by: 2tkCornell on March 29, 2006, 02:35:01 AM
Some possible teams that may sign McKee.  What do you think?

1. New York Islanders
2. Tampa Bay
4. Colorado
4. Washington
5. Anaheim
6. Nashville
Title: Re: Possible Teams That May Sign McKee
Post by: Tub(a) on March 29, 2006, 07:44:50 AM
[quote 2tkCornell]Some possible teams that may sign McKee.  What do you think?

1. New York Islanders
2. Tampa Bay
4. Colorado
4. Washington
5. Anaheim
6. Nashville[/quote]

Are these just off the top of your head?

Isn't Dallas on that list too?
Title: Re: Possible Teams That May Sign McKee
Post by: The Rancor on March 29, 2006, 09:34:14 AM
none of those teams want mckee
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: RatushnyFan on March 29, 2006, 09:50:27 AM
Despite his offensive stats, Johnson clearly hurt Michigan at times with poorly timed penalties, going out of his way to make big hits that led to odd man rushes, etc.  He has the physical talent, but emotionally he's immature.  No way he would go right to the NHL, he would hurt the team.  The kid loves Michigan so why not stick around Ann Arbor (I went to Michigan to get my MBA, Yost is the second best college hockey atmosphere in my view!!), it's a great opportunity.
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: atb9 on March 29, 2006, 10:24:33 AM
:-( Michigan sucks! :-( ;-)
Title: Re: Possible Teams That May Sign McKee
Post by: Jordan 04 on March 29, 2006, 10:26:57 AM
[quote 2tkCornell]Some possible teams that may sign McKee.  What do you think?

1. New York Islanders
[/quote]

On a scale of 1-10, a 14 in craziness.

Oh...wrong thread...
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: RatushnyFan on March 29, 2006, 10:46:12 AM
[quote atb9]:-( Michigan sucks! :-( ;-)[/quote]No, they don't.  Look at their record and accomplishments (this season was really the first bad season since '87-'88).  Their coach is a great guy.  Teams that suck include:  Harvard (obviously), Michigan State (lots of talent, haven't done the job in NCAAs for a long time), Harvard (worth repeating), Minnesota (can't stand 'em even though I'm from MN) and BU.  Discuss.
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: Beeeej on March 29, 2006, 10:48:13 AM
[quote RatushnyFan]No, they don't.  Look at their record and accomplishments (this season was really the first bad season since '87-'88).  Their coach is a great guy.  Teams that suck include:  Harvard (obviously), Michigan State (lots of talent, haven't done the job in NCAAs for a long time), Harvard (worth repeating), Minnesota (can't stand 'em even though I'm from MN) and BU.  Discuss.[/quote]

You forgot Harvard.

Beeeej
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: ninian '72 on March 29, 2006, 11:00:45 AM
Whoa, check the smileys.  Deep breath now... Understandable how Yost could get under the skin of some of the Faithful.  Too much like us, and derivative at that.  Doesn't diminish the quality of the atmosphere.  Also, a whole different style of hockey, which we might not all appreciate.  I.e., if you throw enough speed and creativity into the offensive end, you don't have to play defense too hard, particularly if you have an NHL-bound goalie to back you up.  Red likes to let his guys play.  A lot of the time it works.
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: ugarte on March 29, 2006, 11:09:37 AM
[quote Beeeej][quote RatushnyFan]No, they don't.  Look at their record and accomplishments (this season was really the first bad season since '87-'88).  Their coach is a great guy.  Teams that suck include:  Harvard (obviously), Michigan State (lots of talent, haven't done the job in NCAAs for a long time), Harvard (worth repeating), Minnesota (can't stand 'em even though I'm from MN) and BU.  Discuss.[/quote]

You forgot Harvard.

Beeeej[/quote]Isn't someone going to mention Harvard?
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: RatushnyFan on March 29, 2006, 11:50:03 AM
[quote ninian '72]Whoa, check the smileys.  Deep breath now... Understandable how Yost could get under the skin of some of the Faithful.  Too much like us, and derivative at that.  Doesn't diminish the quality of the atmosphere.  Also, a whole different style of hockey, which we might not all appreciate.  I.e., if you throw enough speed and creativity into the offensive end, you don't have to play defense too hard, particularly if you have an NHL-bound goalie to back you up.  Red likes to let his guys play.  A lot of the time it works.[/quote]While this may reflect the defensive play of the Wolverines in '06, it is not an accurate description from circa '93-'05 in my view.  Some very good defensive clubs and it wasn't all the goaltender.:-)
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: RichH on March 29, 2006, 12:44:34 PM
[quote ugarte][quote Beeeej][quote RatushnyFan]No, they don't.  Look at their record and accomplishments (this season was really the first bad season since '87-'88).  Their coach is a great guy.  Teams that suck include:  Harvard (obviously), Michigan State (lots of talent, haven't done the job in NCAAs for a long time), Harvard (worth repeating), Minnesota (can't stand 'em even though I'm from MN) and BU.  Discuss.[/quote]

You forgot Harvard.

Beeeej[/quote]Isn't someone going to mention Harvard?[/quote]

I was looking for One-and-Done University.
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: Beeeej on March 29, 2006, 12:45:30 PM
[quote RichH]I was looking for One-and-Done University.[/quote]

I really can't stop giggling at "Can'tAdvs."  :-D

Beeeej
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: profudge on March 29, 2006, 04:21:19 PM
I think this is needed maturation and a good thing  

On the other side -  w/ Bill T. from UNO  signing with Coyotes for reportedly somewhere in the 800 - 900K range a year    and now Ryan Potulny from Minn. signing pro with the flyers  I think we will see several more NCAA folks sign soon ...
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: Jeff Hopkins '82 on March 29, 2006, 05:12:49 PM
[quote profudge]I think this is needed maturation and a good thing  

On the other side -  w/ Bill T. from UNO  signing with Coyotes for reportedly somewhere in the 800 - 900K range a year    and now Ryan Potulny from Minn. signing pro with the flyers  I htink we willsee several more NCAA folks sign soon ...[/quote]

I know it's on USCHO, but nothing about Potulny signing on either the Flyers or Phantoms webpage, or on TSN.CA.
Title: Re: Possible Teams That May Sign McKee
Post by: Josh '99 on March 29, 2006, 08:22:53 PM
[quote 2tkCornell]Some possible teams that may sign McKee.  What do you think?

1. New York Islanders[/quote]The Islanders have such an overly inflated opinion of DiPietro (who, by the way, is a great big sieve) that there wouldn't seem to be any desire on their point to sign a new goalie.
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: Josh '99 on March 29, 2006, 08:28:29 PM
[quote RichH][quote ugarte][quote Beeeej][quote RatushnyFan]No, they don't.  Look at their record and accomplishments (this season was really the first bad season since '87-'88).  Their coach is a great guy.  Teams that suck include:  Harvard (obviously), Michigan State (lots of talent, haven't done the job in NCAAs for a long time), Harvard (worth repeating), Minnesota (can't stand 'em even though I'm from MN) and BU.  Discuss.[/quote]

You forgot Harvard.

Beeeej[/quote]Isn't someone going to mention Harvard?[/quote]

I was looking for One-and-Done University.[/quote]Aren't they coached by Ted One-and-Done-ato?
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: redGrinch on March 30, 2006, 12:02:46 AM
[quote Jeff Hopkins '82][quote profudge]I think this is needed maturation and a good thing  

On the other side -  w/ Bill T. from UNO  signing with Coyotes for reportedly somewhere in the 800 - 900K range a year    and now Ryan Potulny from Minn. signing pro with the flyers  I htink we willsee several more NCAA folks sign soon ...[/quote]

I know it's on USCHO, but nothing about Potulny signing on either the Flyers or Phantoms webpage, or on TSN.CA.[/quote]
It's on NHL.com now.  2-year entry deal.

I think a lot of teams would be interested in McKee next season.  Because he was undrafted though, it's hard to figure what his value is.  As point of reference, LeNeveu, a 2nd round draft pick, is making $684k this season.  Jimmy Howard, a 2nd round pick, $640k.  Ryan Miller, a 5th round pick, is making $501k.  Doug Murray, an 8th round pick, is making the league minimum of $450k.  While some teams like Islanders rush their goalies into the NHL; most take a 3-4 year approach.  3-4 years out, unless a team has a stud young goalie, most, if they saw potential, would be willing to take a chance on a player like McKee....  I would agree that McKee needs a few years in the AHL/ECHL to mature and learn the pro game.  I think many on this board would think that Lenny was a better goalie than McKee, and he's kicked around the AHL for 3 seasons before being given a chance for the rest of this season with PHX.
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: mgl11 on March 30, 2006, 06:44:40 AM
The contracts are also way more complicated than just the NHL salary numbers...for most players the entry level NHL contract is a two way contract which pays one salary at the NHL level and another salary at the minor league level (less common would be a one way contract which still pays the player the NHL $$s while in the minors or a three way contract which would split out salary levels for the AHL and ECHL). A player who is on an NHL mininum of 450K would prob draw 60K in the AHL...of course the signing bonus is gaurenteed regardless of where the player plays.

That being said, I have no idea what kind of structure on the contracts the team uses to draw players out of college early. But for somebody like McKee, I think that leaving early to draw whatever signing bonus (which would still be around the next year most likely) plus a salary of 60K, couldn't be that much of a draw. Unless a team is giving him a one way deal or telling him that he could spend some serious time in the NHL next -- I just don't see the financial reason for him to bolt.
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: Jeff Hopkins '82 on March 30, 2006, 08:02:08 AM
Potulny announcement now on the Flyers webpage.  He's not listed on the roster for either team yet.
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: jy3 on March 30, 2006, 06:26:30 PM
http://sports.yahoo.com/ncaah/news?slug=uwire-minnesotaspotulnytosigncon&prov=uwire&type=lgns
yep here too
maybe we should cahnge this thread title to 2006 defections
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: calgARI '07 on March 30, 2006, 06:58:18 PM
He'll be joining the Phantoms at this weekend.
Title: Re: Johnson Stays At Michigan
Post by: adamw on March 31, 2006, 06:47:57 PM
Potulny can't play for the Phantoms, due to something in his contract.  In speaking to him today, the idea is that he sticks around for insurance if Nedved and/or Gagne can't go - and would probably get a look.  But he won't be playing yet.