ELynah Forum

General Category => Hockey => Topic started by: Red Man on April 22, 2004, 02:06:24 PM

Title: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: Red Man on April 22, 2004, 02:06:24 PM
Frankly I could not think of many great ones.  Anyone want to add to this list:

1.) Dryden
2.) Nieuwndyk
3.) Oats
4.) St. Louis (needs to do the same thing for a few before he really qualifies)
5.) LeClair


Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: Greg on April 22, 2004, 03:15:54 PM
Dave Taylor (Clarkson)

Brian Hayward (Cornell)

Rod Langway (UNH)

Daren Puppa (RPI)

Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: ugarte on April 22, 2004, 04:19:00 PM
Joe Juneau (RPI)
Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: Al DeFlorio on April 22, 2004, 04:29:58 PM
[Q]Greg Wrote:

 Dave Taylor (Clarkson)

Brian Hayward (Cornell)

Rod Langway (UNH)

Daren Puppa (RPI)


Edited 2 times. Last edit at 04/22/04 03:20PM by Greg.[/q]
BU's (1973-1977) Ricky Meagher had a pretty good NHL career.  Won the Selke Trophy in 1990.

Brown's Curt Bennett had two 30 goal seasons among his ten or so NHL years.

RPI's Joe Juneau is approaching 600 career NHL points in thirteen seasons.

Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: KenP on April 22, 2004, 04:46:44 PM
Sucks' Ted Donato has 347 points over his career, including 54, 51 and 49-point seasons.  I don't think he falls under the category of "best", but that's certainly respectable.
Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: jkahn on April 22, 2004, 05:31:11 PM
Joe Mullen (BC) was an outstanding college and NHL player.  He, Joe and Oates should be the first line of NHLers who were ECAC players.

Craig Conroy (Clarkson) centers Calgary's first line and is a real solid player.

Jack O'Callahan (BU) was a decent NHL defenseman for about eight seasons, mostly with Chicago.  

[Q]BU's (1973-1977) Ricky Meagher had a pretty good NHL career[/Q]
Just some added info on Meagher....in '76-77 he was (in this reporter's opinion) the standout on a great BU line with future Olympians Mike Eruzione and Dave Silk. O'Callahan and Jim Craig were also on that team.
Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: cbuckser on April 22, 2004, 09:35:17 PM
Here is my lineup:
G   Ken Dryden (Cornell)
G   Daren Puppa (RPI)
D   Rod Langway (UNH)
D   Don Sweeney (Harvard)
D   Aaron Miller (Vermont)
D   Jim Korn (Providence)
D   Mike Milbury (Colgate)
D   Todd Simpson (Brown)
F   Dave Taylor (Clarkson)
F   Joe Nieuwendyk (Cornell)
F   Adam Oates (RPI)
F   Joe Mullen (BC)
F   Joe Juneau (RPI)
F   John LeClair (Vermont)
F   Martin St. Louis (Vermont)
F   Doug Brown (BC)
F   Kevin Stevens (BC)
F   John Cullen (BU)
F   Rick Meagher (BU)
F   Todd Marchant (Clarkson)


Here are some others who, in my mind, just barely miss the cut:
G   Chris Terreri (Providence)
D   Peter Taglianetti (Providence)
F   Ted Donato (Harvard)
F   Randy Wood (Yale)
F   Chris Nilan (Northeastern)


   The depth at forward is far better than at the other positions.  If I were coaching this team, I would want Rod Langway to play at least 30 minutes each game.  I'd also play mind games with Mike Milbury to extract revenge for his stupid trades.   If Zneda Chara wins the Norris Trophy, I'd scratch Mad Mike out of spite.
Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: dss28 on April 22, 2004, 11:55:36 PM
And Sucks's Steve Moore, before he got hurt...
Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: the rancor on April 23, 2004, 12:03:14 AM
kent manderville?
Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: ninian '72 on April 23, 2004, 07:54:41 AM
Jeff Halpern (Princeton)
Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: Greg on April 23, 2004, 08:15:31 AM
Todd White (Clarkson) had 50+ points in each of his first two full NHL seasons.
Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: O.S.B. on April 27, 2004, 03:59:47 PM
Zdeno Chara should def. be in their and Eric Cole should get an honorable mention, he isn't a big stats guy but he greatly helps his team every game
Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: Dingus on April 27, 2004, 04:16:23 PM
Zdeno Chara???

Forgive my ignorance, but which ECAC team did he play for?
Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: Greg Berge on April 27, 2004, 06:01:39 PM
Zdeno Chara played junior hockey with Prince George.  The closest he ever got to the ECAC was a straight A average in junior college (equivalent to a Harvard honors degree).
Title: Re: Best NHL players from the ECAC
Post by: cbuckser on April 27, 2004, 06:40:43 PM
I omitted guys like Jeff Halpern, Todd White, and Erik Cole because, in my opinion, they have not had careers as good as the players who have retired or are in their sunset years of their careers.  Martin St. Louis is the obvious exception, which he earned with his Hart Trophy nomination.  The other younger guys may earn spots on my list, but they have not done so yet.  It's the same concept of a great, young player not having earned a spot in the Hall of Fame despite being on a trajectory to get there.