How bad could it be? Musungu back. Bass-Salpezio named starting QB. Into the breach.
Quote from: ugarte on September 19, 2026, 11:04:15 AMHow bad could it be? Musungu back. Bass-Salpezio named starting QB. Into the breach.
It could be bad. Colgate is playing their 4 game and Cornell will likely have 1st game miscues. Colgate nearly beat a FBS school in Central Michigan. Colgate has an outstanding running attack and a big DL on defense. I hope it will be competitive and Cornell escapes with no major injuries.
Quote from: Ken711 on September 19, 2026, 11:52:26 AMQuote from: ugarte on September 19, 2026, 11:04:15 AMHow bad could it be? Musungu back. Bass-Salpezio named starting QB. Into the breach.
It could be bad. Colgate is playing their 4 game and Cornell will likely have 1st game miscues. Colgate nearly beat a FBS school in Central Michigan. Colgate has an outstanding running attack and a big DL on defense. I hope it will be competitive and Cornell escapes with no major injuries.
I was joking. I expected a blowout and just as I turned the game on, Colgate made it 17-0 not quite midway through the 2d quarter.
28 days, 4 hours and 36 minutes until face off with Waterloo.
Would like to see an underclass QB given a chance.
Never seen a fake field goal attempt run straight ahead into the line.
Quote from: Al DeFlorio on September 19, 2026, 02:38:33 PMWould like to see an underclass QB given a chance.
certainly the earliest call for a qb controversy I've seen.
defense has improved over the course of the game, including on the blitz.
With two 20+ yard delayed draws, GBS has us in the red zone.
TD Triplett on the option! Shutout over. 20-7 with 10:22 to go.
And that's the final. 20-0 at the half, 20-7 final. We got a number of sacks off of blitzes, caused a few turnovers and put together a real drive with GBS using his legs. We couldn't get anyone open, though, and that's not going to work for this offense.
Defense playing calling is better with the new DC. I really think they need to run the ball more to open up the passing game more.
I am beginning to think Dan Swanstrom was a terrible hire for Cornell. He was a good DIII coach at Ithaca College but the Ivy League is a huge step up from that level. He's now in his third year and nearly all the starters are Archer recruits. Look at Harvard and Yale as those two schools recruit football players who are Division I caliber and Cornell continues under perform in recruiting. We certainly don't recruit that way in ice hockey or lacrosse, but year after year football remains in the bottom half of the Ivy League standings. We have not posted a winning record in 21 years and our last Ivy League title was in 1990. As a local alum who has donated to this program for many years its very frustrating.
Sure Colgate was on their fourth game, but Harvard blew out UNH 31-7 and Yale beat Holy Cross 38-28. Those two teams showed up ready to play!
Quote from: Local Motion on September 20, 2026, 09:46:21 PMI am beginning to think Dan Swanstrom was a terrible hire for Cornell. He was a good DIII coach at Ithaca College but the Ivy League is a huge step up from that level. He's now in his third year and nearly all the starters are Archer recruits. Look at Harvard and Yale as those two schools recruit football players who are Division I caliber and Cornell continues under perform in recruiting. We certainly don't recruit that way in ice hockey or lacrosse, but year after year football remains in the bottom half of the Ivy League standings. We have not posted a winning record in 21 years and our last Ivy League title was in 1990. As a local alum who has donated to this program for many years its very frustrating.
Sure Colgate was on their fourth game, but Harvard blew out UNH 31-7 and Yale beat Holy Cross 38-28. Those two teams showed up ready to play!
The second part of your post disproves the first part. First you say Swanstrom was a bad hire. Then you mention that nobody else has won in 21 years. Clearly, this is a Cornell problem, not a coaching problem. I understand the frustration but calling Swanstrom a "terrible hire" when he is doing no worse than the last six or seven coaches is asinine.
Back to back 3-4 conference finishes probably ranks him in the top 20% of Cornell coaches all-time.
Quote from: Local Motion on September 20, 2026, 09:46:21 PMI am beginning to think Dan Swanstrom was a terrible hire for Cornell. He was a good DIII coach at Ithaca College but the Ivy League is a huge step up from that level. He's now in his third year and nearly all the starters are Archer recruits. Look at Harvard and Yale as those two schools recruit football players who are Division I caliber and Cornell continues under perform in recruiting. We certainly don't recruit that way in ice hockey or lacrosse, but year after year football remains in the bottom half of the Ivy League standings. We have not posted a winning record in 21 years and our last Ivy League title was in 1990. As a local alum who has donated to this program for many years its very frustrating.
Sure Colgate was on their fourth game, but Harvard blew out UNH 31-7 and Yale beat Holy Cross 38-28. Those two teams showed up ready to play!
Silly post. You want a team to start all freshman and sophomores (Swanstrom's recruits)? In what world will Cornell out recruit Harvard and Yale in football. You can add Princeton into the name recognition schools as well that will ALWAYS be attractive to football recruits. The program suffered under Archer for over a decade, it takes time to dig out of that mess.
Quote from: ugarte on September 21, 2026, 10:40:50 AMBack to back 3-4 conference finishes probably ranks him in the top 20% of Cornell coaches all-time.
Seriously. I think we'd all sign for 3-4 ivy wins every year and occasional meaningful games in late November. Perennial mediocrity would be a big improvement.
Quote from: Chris '03 on September 21, 2026, 01:26:33 PMQuote from: ugarte on September 21, 2026, 10:40:50 AMBack to back 3-4 conference finishes probably ranks him in the top 20% of Cornell coaches all-time.
Seriously. I think we'd all sign for 3-4 ivy wins every year and occasional meaningful games in late November. Perennial mediocrity would be a big improvement.
I definitely wouldn't sign up for that. The goal is to win the Ivy, not be mediocre every year.
Quote from: BearLover on September 21, 2026, 03:38:10 PMQuote from: Chris '03 on September 21, 2026, 01:26:33 PMQuote from: ugarte on September 21, 2026, 10:40:50 AMBack to back 3-4 conference finishes probably ranks him in the top 20% of Cornell coaches all-time.
Seriously. I think we'd all sign for 3-4 ivy wins every year and occasional meaningful games in late November. Perennial mediocrity would be a big improvement.
I definitely wouldn't sign up for that. The goal is to win the Ivy, not be mediocre every year.
being a bit literal there. eventually we'd all find it frustrating but in light of recent incompetence I'm inclined to give him a longer runway unless his four-class teams backslide to Archer levels.
Quote from: ugarte on September 21, 2026, 03:45:42 PMQuote from: BearLover on September 21, 2026, 03:38:10 PMQuote from: Chris '03 on September 21, 2026, 01:26:33 PMQuote from: ugarte on September 21, 2026, 10:40:50 AMBack to back 3-4 conference finishes probably ranks him in the top 20% of Cornell coaches all-time.
Seriously. I think we'd all sign for 3-4 ivy wins every year and occasional meaningful games in late November. Perennial mediocrity would be a big improvement.
I definitely wouldn't sign up for that. The goal is to win the Ivy, not be mediocre every year.
being a bit literal there. eventually we'd all find it frustrating but in light of recent incompetence I'm inclined to give him a longer runway unless his four-class teams backslide to Archer levels.
Oh I definitely agree with that.
It's both a Cornell and a coaching problem. I went to the game on Saturday and we barely in our seats and Cornell was down 14-0 in the first quarter. Agreed Colgate is a better team and they were on their fourth game, but I thought we would at least be somewhat competitive. As per my prior post, Cornell is very competitive in both ice hockey and lacrosse, meanwhile we alums are giving money to football year after year with literally no progress. In the second half Colgate was trying not to run up the score, as they played very conservatively running the ball to eat up the clock. Agreed our other football coaches have not been very good either, but look at Colgate as their coach is in his second season and they are 4-0. Why didn't Cornell hire that coach???
Quote from: Local Motion on September 21, 2026, 05:49:07 PMIt's both a Cornell and a coaching problem. I went to the game on Saturday and we barely in our seats and Cornell was down 14-0 in the first quarter. Agreed Colgate is a better team and they were on their fourth game, but I thought we would at least be somewhat competitive. As per my prior post, Cornell is very competitive in both ice hockey and lacrosse, meanwhile we alums are giving money to football year after year with literally no progress. In the second half Colgate was trying not to run up the score, as they played very conservatively running the ball to eat up the clock. Agreed our other football coaches have not been very good either, but look at Colgate as their coach is in his second season and they are 4-0. Why didn't Cornell hire that coach???
Colgate is the 2nd best team and possibly the best in the Patriot League. Colgate can offer scholarships, and has less restrictive admission requirements. BTW, Colgate is 3-1 and that coach wasn't left with the mess of a program that Archer made in 12 years heading the football program. I get it you are frustrated, but your expectations of being in the top tier in the Ivy League in year 3 at Cornell is not realistic. The bigger question is why the athletic department and the administration stuck with Archer for 12 years. Not the hiring of coach Swanstrom.
Quote from: Local Motion on September 21, 2026, 05:49:07 PM... we barely in our seats and Cornell was down 14-0 in the first quarter...
and how did the rest of the game go, defensively
Punter looks good from the stats, anyway.
Thought the defense played really well in the 2nd half and I liked the level of pursuit they showed after getting pushed around in the 1st half. Cornell's offense struggled to get chunk plays outside of GSB's qb runs on the touchdown drive. I attribute the lack of success of offense to the speed of the Colgate defense-the linebackers were really good. As to Cornell's lack of success recently-Cornell's football budget in the Ivy League is in the lower half and that is even after they added funding to the budget with Swanstrom's hire. Coach Swanstrom has openly admitted that they cannot out recruit HYP. His role model is Dartmouth where they bring in talent and develop it. Let's give him a couple more seasons before we pass judgement.