ELynah Forum

General Category => Hockey => Topic started by: Beeeej on August 28, 2018, 09:04:06 AM

Title: 1967 NCAA Men's Hockey Championship Game Puck on eBay
Post by: Beeeej on August 28, 2018, 09:04:06 AM
I'm not the seller, but I thought folks here might be interested in something like this.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1967-Cornell-Boston-University-Men-s-Hockey-NCAA-Championship-Game-Puck-/123332226295
Title: Re: 1967 NCAA Men's Hockey Championship Game Puck on eBay
Post by: Trotsky on August 28, 2018, 02:26:52 PM
Holy shit.

I'm not a collector but my god that's the Holy Grail.

One of you rich shitheads needs to buy that so I can see it.
Title: Re: 1967 NCAA Men's Hockey Championship Game Puck on eBay
Post by: LGR14 on August 28, 2018, 02:52:45 PM
Any way to authenticate it ahead of time?
Title: Re: 1967 NCAA Men's Hockey Championship Game Puck on eBay
Post by: Beeeej on August 28, 2018, 09:09:24 PM
The description acknowledges that he cannot say for certain it's the game puck from that game.
Title: Re: 1967 NCAA Men's Hockey Championship Game Puck on eBay
Post by: Roy 82 on August 29, 2018, 01:16:03 AM
Quote from: BeeeejThe description acknowledges that he cannot say for certain it's the game puck from that game.

Hmmm. A bit of amateur sleuthing: In 1964 Tyer Rubber company became Converse and the puck logo should reflect that if it is from 1967 (maybe they got a deal on old pucks?). The puck logo  on eBay says "Tyer".

The description states: "Found in the basement of a deceased Cornell professor in Ithaca".
I would contact the seller (who appears to be a professional dealer) and ask for the name of the professor.
Title: Re: 1967 NCAA Men's Hockey Championship Game Puck on eBay
Post by: Jim Hyla on August 29, 2018, 08:06:28 AM
Quote from: Roy 82
Quote from: BeeeejThe description acknowledges that he cannot say for certain it's the game puck from that game.

Hmmm. A bit of amateur sleuthing: In 1964 Tyer Rubber company became Converse and the puck logo should reflect that if it is from 1967 (maybe they got a deal on old pucks?). The puck logo  on eBay says "Tyer".

The description states: "Found in the basement of a deceased Cornell professor in Ithaca".
I would contact the seller (who appears to be a professional dealer) and ask for the name of the professor.

Andover Answers says they were bought in 1961, (https://answers.mhl.org/index.php/Tyer_Rubber_Company) which would seem to make it even less likely. But I did ask the seller some questions.
Title: Re: 1967 NCAA Men's Hockey Championship Game Puck on eBay
Post by: billhoward on August 29, 2018, 12:22:02 PM
The tape has that patina of authenticity, looking like a used civil war bandage.

Look at the date, BTW: Most years, that's the week leading up to the ECAC title game. Now there's 3-4 more weeks left in the season.
Title: Re: 1967 NCAA Men's Hockey Championship Game Puck on eBay
Post by: David Harding on August 31, 2018, 12:01:36 AM
Quote from: Jim Hyla
Quote from: Roy 82
Quote from: BeeeejThe description acknowledges that he cannot say for certain it's the game puck from that game.

Hmmm. A bit of amateur sleuthing: In 1964 Tyer Rubber company became Converse and the puck logo should reflect that if it is from 1967 (maybe they got a deal on old pucks?). The puck logo  on eBay says "Tyer".

The description states: "Found in the basement of a deceased Cornell professor in Ithaca".
I would contact the seller (who appears to be a professional dealer) and ask for the name of the professor.

Andover Answers says they were bought in 1961, (https://answers.mhl.org/index.php/Tyer_Rubber_Company) which would seem to make it even less likely. But I did ask the seller some questions.
In this collection of pucks  http://llcgunner.wixsite.com/nyrangerspucks/grid , the Tyer name persists well into the 1970's.
Title: Re: 1967 NCAA Men's Hockey Championship Game Puck on eBay
Post by: LGR14 on August 31, 2018, 09:35:12 AM
Quote from: David Harding
Quote from: Jim Hyla
Quote from: Roy 82
Quote from: BeeeejThe description acknowledges that he cannot say for certain it's the game puck from that game.

Hmmm. A bit of amateur sleuthing: In 1964 Tyer Rubber company became Converse and the puck logo should reflect that if it is from 1967 (maybe they got a deal on old pucks?). The puck logo  on eBay says "Tyer".

The description states: "Found in the basement of a deceased Cornell professor in Ithaca".
I would contact the seller (who appears to be a professional dealer) and ask for the name of the professor.

Andover Answers says they were bought in 1961, (https://answers.mhl.org/index.php/Tyer_Rubber_Company) which would seem to make it even less likely. But I did ask the seller some questions.
In this collection of pucks  http://llcgunner.wixsite.com/nyrangerspucks/grid , the Tyer name persists well into the 1970's.

I see it stopping in 1964?
Title: Re: 1967 NCAA Men's Hockey Championship Game Puck on eBay
Post by: Jim Hyla on August 31, 2018, 03:53:17 PM
Quote from: LGR14
Quote from: David Harding
Quote from: Jim Hyla
Quote from: Roy 82
Quote from: BeeeejThe description acknowledges that he cannot say for certain it's the game puck from that game.

Hmmm. A bit of amateur sleuthing: In 1964 Tyer Rubber company became Converse and the puck logo should reflect that if it is from 1967 (maybe they got a deal on old pucks?). The puck logo  on eBay says "Tyer".

The description states: "Found in the basement of a deceased Cornell professor in Ithaca".
I would contact the seller (who appears to be a professional dealer) and ask for the name of the professor.

Andover Answers says they were bought in 1961, (https://answers.mhl.org/index.php/Tyer_Rubber_Company) which would seem to make it even less likely. But I did ask the seller some questions.
In this collection of pucks  http://llcgunner.wixsite.com/nyrangerspucks/grid , the Tyer name persists well into the 1970's.

I see it stopping in 1964?

Me too. The Art Ross Tyer, by Converse, went later, but the Tyer Rubber Company was last in the 62-64 section.

In my opinion, that makes the 67 Championship much less likely to be legit. I don't know that the NCAA, or Syracuse Stars, would be using 3 year old pucks.

We'll probably never know.

I don't know that I'm going to spring a couple of hundred bucks for it.
Title: Re: 1967 NCAA Men's Hockey Championship Game Puck on eBay
Post by: Jim Hyla on September 01, 2018, 09:04:56 PM
Sold for $480. Insane!