Crease Size
Posted by Dingus
Crease Size
Posted by: Dingus (---.prenhall.com)
Date: April 12, 2004 05:36PM
Okay, I know this is a little late, but in watching the replay of Maine's goal that was called off, am I the only one (other than my brother) who thinks that if they were playing on a college rink, with the semi-circle crease, as opposed to the newer crease used in the NHL, that Maine's goal would have counted...
In watching those replays, I do not believe that a Maine skater would have been in the crease, given that the college crease doesn't go up quite as far to the sides of the goalie... And, the puck itself may actually have been in the crease before the Maine player shot it, had they been using the typical college crease..
Any thoughts, or I am really just losing it?
In watching those replays, I do not believe that a Maine skater would have been in the crease, given that the college crease doesn't go up quite as far to the sides of the goalie... And, the puck itself may actually have been in the crease before the Maine player shot it, had they been using the typical college crease..
Any thoughts, or I am really just losing it?
Re: Crease Size
Posted by: Kyle Rose (---.cmbrmaks.akamai.com)
Date: April 12, 2004 05:43PM
I just think it's an inane rule. I honestly couldn't give two shits who won the game, but to have it decided on a technicality is just ridiculous. There's no way that skate had any effect on whether the puck went into the net or not, illustrating the folly of such a broad rule.
Cheers,
Kyle
Cheers,
Kyle
Re: Crease Size
Posted by: Dingus (---.prenhall.com)
Date: April 12, 2004 05:54PM
But I understand why the rule is there... I actually like (I think) that it's not subjective in any way, and that it doesn't come down to the referee's discretion as to whether or not the goalie was interfered with... You go in the crease, the play stops... Simple as that... No confusion...
Back to the question, though... Do you think that if the game was played with a typical college crease, rather than the square NHL one, that the player would still have been in the crease?
Back to the question, though... Do you think that if the game was played with a typical college crease, rather than the square NHL one, that the player would still have been in the crease?
Re: Crease Size
Posted by: KeithK (---.external.lmco.com)
Date: April 12, 2004 06:19PM
Can someone point to a diagram(s) showing the crease dimensions of each? I though the NHL had just chopped the sides off - didn't know they'd also changed other dimensions. (I'll let someone else do the Google-ing on this.) The Maine player was near the edge, so I suppose it's possible.
Re: Crease Size
Posted by: Tub(a) (---.resnet.cornell.edu)
Date: April 12, 2004 07:05PM
[Q]Dingus Wrote:
But I understand why the rule is there... I actually like (I think) that it's not subjective in any way, and that it doesn't come down to the referee's discretion as to whether or not the goalie was interfered with... You go in the crease, the play stops... Simple as that... No confusion...
[/q]
[bitter]While that's the way it's intended to be, the clearcut rule may be ignored if it's the deciding goal of the Stanley Cup Finals[/bitter]... wait, who am I kidding... [always bitter Buffalo sports fan]
But I understand why the rule is there... I actually like (I think) that it's not subjective in any way, and that it doesn't come down to the referee's discretion as to whether or not the goalie was interfered with... You go in the crease, the play stops... Simple as that... No confusion...
[/q]
[bitter]While that's the way it's intended to be, the clearcut rule may be ignored if it's the deciding goal of the Stanley Cup Finals[/bitter]... wait, who am I kidding... [always bitter Buffalo sports fan]
Re: Crease Size
Posted by: Dingus (---.nyc.rr.com)
Date: April 12, 2004 07:27PM
While I was certainly rooting for Buffalo in that series, I can't complain too much about Dallas winning since it resulted in Joey bringing me the Stanley Cup!!!
GO TUBA!!!!
GO TUBA!!!!
Re: Crease Size
Posted by: ben03 (---.nyc.rr.com)
Date: April 12, 2004 08:31PM
have at it ...
[www.nhl.com]
www.ncaa.org/library/rules/2003/ice_hockey_rules.pdf
[www.nhl.com]
www.ncaa.org/library/rules/2003/ice_hockey_rules.pdf
___________________________
Let's GO Red!!!
Let's GO Red!!!
Re: Crease Size
Posted by: Avash (---.twcny.rr.com)
Date: April 12, 2004 10:58PM
[Q]ben03 Wrote:
have at it ...
[www.nhl.com]
www.ncaa.org/library/rules/2003/ice_hockey_rules.pdf[/q]
The diagram of the NCAA crease is on page 17 of the latter link. Looks the same as the NHL crease to me.
have at it ...
[www.nhl.com]
www.ncaa.org/library/rules/2003/ice_hockey_rules.pdf[/q]
The diagram of the NCAA crease is on page 17 of the latter link. Looks the same as the NHL crease to me.
Re: Crease Size
Posted by: pat (---.er.usgs.gov)
Date: April 13, 2004 09:42AM
To be precise, they're both based on a "semi-circle six feet. . .in radius."
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.